So Close, But Not Quite…
… or, How I’ve almost helped the publishing industry.
Regular readers of this site know that I enjoy books. From that information, it should be clear that I’ve been very concerned about the recent deluge of bad news emanating from the publishing industry. I feel especially bad when I read most book-blogs these days: the gentle entreaties to get out there and buy a whole mess of books if I can always makes me feel as though I am as capable of providing support as a damp washcloth.
All of the unresolved, free-floating, penitential anxiety I have — a legacy of my fundamentalist upbringing — seems to have coalesced around this subject. So, consider this a confession of sorts; of course, since the particular strain of faith-based shame I was brought up under originates from the New England, puritan branch, I know I’m damned no matter what I do. Nevertheless, here are all the ways I came this close to helping out the book industry in 2008.
- Good: I bought a lot of books. Bad: Most were used books:
Well, what do you expect from a guy who publishes an (admittedly irregular) series called the "100 Penny Review". What can I say? The local friends of the library continues to have these really huge book sales on a regular basis, which I can’t seem to avoid. Twenty-five cent paperbacks are my kryptonite. Of course, none of those twenty-five cents actually goes to the authors whose books I’m buying; no, the library gets the lot! Which brings us to…
- Good: I read a lot. Bad: I borrow books a lot:
While I have as acquisitive nature as the next guy, I’m not above borrowing books from the library. (I also borrow movies and CD’s, but that’s another blog post.) Again, I’m not directly contributing to an author’s income, nor the bottom line of any big publisher — and yet, I’m getting the benefit of their products. And, as it turns out, libraries aren’t even profit-generating capitalist ventures, but rather a shared public resource. So, I might even be some sort of communist, too.
- Good: I finished a lot of books this year. Bad: I did not burn them:
Here’s a place where I’ve accumulated a large quantity of guilt, based on the fact that I’ve yet to come up with a satisfactory resolution to one of the greatest ethical questions of our age: what does one do with books that one is finished with?
Okay, I know what the ethical answer is, of course. I just can’t bring myself to follow through with it. I treat my books gently — even the ones I know I’ll never re-read or refer to again — so I always wind up with mint condition books that I have no further use for. The problem is that any functioning book that’s not currently on a shelf in a bookstore is a dangerous object. I’ve been handing them off to friends and co-workers, donating them to the library, thereby depriving he publishing industry of valuable income. Every book given is a book that will not be purchased.
Obviously, the only ethical choice here is to burn used books. This would guarantee that any of the new books I’ve purchased will have had one and only one reader, which is how books are meant to be used. If you want to read a copy of William Gibson’s Spook Country, by god, you won’t be getting it from me.
Except that I’m not really set up for book-burnings. They generate a lot of smoke and ash, and I’m not equipped to deal with all that. It seems to me that this should be a service provided by the community. That way, we can all come together to help the publishing industry in a safe, fire-code appropriate way. Actually, we could probably just stand in a circle and heave books on to the smoldering remains of our book-business-destroying local libraries. That ought to do it.

